Jump to content

Auction madness and competition.


Dafydd

Recommended Posts

I was surprised to see this lot offered in next Saturday's N&N of London Auction 20.

This lot represents a pleasant surprise directed towards our esteemed customers. The image of this particular lot is exclusively accessible to the Bid...

Here are the lot details.

This lot represents a pleasant surprise directed towards our esteemed customers. The image of this particular lot is exclusively accessible to the Biddr management and will remain undisclosed until the completion of the auction. Subsequently, the highest bidder shall be granted the privilege of acquiring this coin, which could potentially be of low or high value, thereby contributing to the overall anticipation and element of surprise. We cordially extend an invitation to participate in the bidding process for this undisclosed item. May fortune favor your endeavors!

 

You have read it correctly, you are bidding blind for something that could be of low or high value!

The current bidding stands at £300 /$385 with 11 bids. This is a clever device based on greed and intrigue. Most people would assume that the coin would have to be good for the auction house to avoid criticism. 

Am I missing out on a Aureus or that elusive lifetime portrait of Julius Caesar for maybe $500, or would my surprise be another Gloria Exercitus Contantine Follis but in great condition? Personally I am not prepared to take the gamble of possibly acquiring something outside of my collecting interests for hundreds of pounds.  However, whatever the coin is, you could hardly complain having bid blind.

I am not that cynical but it did occur to me that once the initial auction is finished, this would be a great way to unload high value but unattractive coins in the future. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder and priced catalogues can never determine an individuals preference for colour or tone. But I digress.

I thought I would celebrate this interesting new auction house device with a competition to run simultaneously. I will offer a prize to whoever guesses the closest to what the surprise lot is. Please be specific to avoid ties and first closest answer wins. 

I will take a little mystery out of the prize by stating that the winner can choose between a Roman coin or a British coin and I will ship anywhere.

My money, metaphorically speaking, is on a Greek coin as this auction features more Greek coins than anything else. I know little about Greek coinage so wouldn't hazard a guess myself.

Winner will be announced after the Auction reveals what the surprise lot is.

Good luck to those that enter.

Edited by Dafydd
Typo
  • Like 14
  • Cookie 1
  • Gasp 1
  • Thinking 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I won't lie I would be curious to see what it is (if they don't reveal it at the end, only to the winner I think there will be a riot), and since Biddr knows so there can be no switcheroo. And if it is a low value coin then there will similarly be an uproar, and nobody will participate in the next such thing. So, I think that it is something that is high value, probably not rare or in exceptional condition.

Since you are offering a prize I might as well hazard a guess, I think that it will be a Lysimachos Tetradrachm. Not based on anything, but that is what my gut is telling me.

But I think that this is a really scummy tactic tbh, and I do not support auction houses making use of this kind of Gatcha method.

  • Like 8
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I thought this was absolutely mad, who on earth would participate in this?

N&N London (Location:London, coins shipped from Belgium) are ambiguous about their location, and land you with a £35 shipping charge. Therefore, they would be the last house I would engage in such a gamble with.

  • Like 6
Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 hours ago, Steppenfool said:

I thought this was absolutely mad, who on earth would participate in this?

 

N&N London (Location:London, coins shipped from Belgium) are ambiguous abut their location, and land you with a £35 shipping charge. Therefore, they would be the last house I would engage in such a gamble with.

 

I agree with @Steppenfool quite mad. 

 

I bought a couple of coins from them last month assuming they were based in London. The initial invoice added £35 and I complained as I said they had insinuated they were based in London. The charge was withdrawn and I had the opportunity to pay £10 for mail. The coins turned up a couple of days later with no drama. In the past I have bought a couple of inexpensive coins at Savoca and they held them for me until the next auction as the DHL charge was more than the coins so I consolidated them with something else.

The coins I bought from N&N  were

Lot 343   Honorius. AD 393-423. Æ Follis (19mm, 5.58 g) DN HONORIVS PF AVG. Pearl-diademed... Honorius Follis Hammer £4.00 GBP

HADRIAN, (A.D. 117-138), AE AS, (12.56 Gr. 25 mm.) Rome
Laureate draped bust to right of Hadrian
Rev. Fortuna-Concordia standing left holding patera and cornucopiae, S C across.  Hammer £20.00 GBP.

Lot 411 HADRIAN, (A.D. 117-138), AE AS, (12.56 Gr. 25 mm.) Rome Laureate draped bust to ...

Edited by Dafydd
Wrong price quoted on Honorius
  • Like 9
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would never participate, but at least 7 bidders disagree 😁 My uneducated guess is their lot no. 50, which was withdrawn. Obviously that's the coin for the winner of lot no. 1! Either fake (low value), or real (higher value), it's a surprise either way. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

This N&N London scheme seems certain to create ill will, unless the coin is way more valuable than the highest bid. But, N&N London has no idea, what the highest bid will be. Therefore, it seems like a risky scheme, to me. $385 is a lot of money to me. But perhaps, for someone with deep pockets, $385 is worth it, just for the fun of it, and for the prestige of it, and for the chance to win a very valuable coin for a low price. Like buying a very expensive lottery ticket. Perhaps this is a creative way to legally gamble, in countries where gambling is illegal (are there any such countries? I don't know). It  would be interesting to see, what the final hammer price will be, and what the actual coin is.

Edited by sand
  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

N&N has certainly benefitted from the auction of the mystery coin since we are all talking about it.  Free publicity.  Personally, I will not bid, but if I had money to burn, I might.  But the more bids that are placed, the higher the hammer price, and the less likelihood that the winner will be happy.  

  • Like 5
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Benefactor
10 minutes ago, AETHER said:

They will pick and choose what the prize is after they see the final bid. 

Not unless you suspect the Biddr management of being in on the scam. If you reread the OP, you'll see that your concern has been addressed.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Benefactor

This is not something I would participate in, but obviously its got at least two people willing to try it out so far.  My wild guess is that it will be a Greek tetradrachm of some sort.  But, value is an entirely relative concept.  The winner may not have any interest in what they get and not see any value to it.  Anyway, its an interesting side note to the hobby and business, and one I am guessing will not be repeated (at least not by anyone else).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

First of all, let's talk about N&N London itself. I have nothing bad to say about the auction house in general. I always find interesting coins there - especially Roman provinces. When I won, the auction house was always serious - after payment, my coins were always delivered very quickly.


About the action. I see it in two ways. Maybe it shouldn't be taken so seriously - it's a little game. It also loosens up the landscape of auctions a bit - maybe. But is it really reprehensible? Does anyone know these travel suitcase auctions at airports and train stations. Here, too, they auction blindly. And you can be lucky or unlucky. And there are also other auctions - where a container or pallet is auctioned blind. Has anyone ever been upset about that?

But what is important. No matter whether a suitcase, a pallet, a container - or, as in this case, a coin - is auctioned off, no one is forced to take part!

Of course, the curiosity of the interested parties is played with - but that is no different with the suitcase auction. But the good thing is - people who enjoy it should bid - I don't have to.

People - we are all adults - you don't always have to want everyone to be protected from everything 🙂

  • Like 8
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...